Of course it was true! "Oliver Harpur's body was found. Shot once though the hat, the other more fatal." Who could make that up?
"Jason Treadwell, being convicted of the murder of Oliver Harper, was hanged from a tree on July 29th, near the location where Oliver Harpur's body was found in the gulley on the Old Road to Harmony"
Though these quotes are not from Blackman, some of the events are detailed in Emily Blackman's History of Susquehanna County.
A few facts were embellished for the benefit of camp lore, e.g. Jason Treadwell was a local laborer, not a drifter, and Oliver Harpur was a treasure hunter financier, not a quarry owner. The true story is more unbelievable than the camp story.
Our story begins with an old tale of Spaniards boating up the Susquehanna who buried gold and silver along its banks near the town of Susquehanna. Whether this tale was fabricated by a man named Joe Smith is not clear, though there is no evidence of treasure toting Spaniards on the Susquehanna.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Joe Smith's original occupation among the money-diggers appears to have been that of a "peeper" or "treasure witch." It seems likely that Smith took over those duties for local money-diggers after the predictions and directions of a certain lady named Odle (or O'Dell) proved useless. The financier of the c. 1823-24 money-digging operations in the Great Bend area was Oliver Harper. Harper's eventual partner in the treasure hunting was Josiah Stowell. Either Stowell or Harper (or both together) contracted the services of Joseph Smith, Jr. (as a replacement for the "peeper" O'Dell) some time prior to Harper's death (by murder) in May of 1824. On page 97 of her history, Blackman reports that "Oliver Harper was murdered by Jason Treadwell." On page 325, she says that Treadwell was executed for the murder on January 13, 1825. Some reports say that Treadwell was a member of Harper's money-digging crew and that he and another man were incited to kill Harper after Joseph Smith, Jr. announced that one of the company would have to die before a certain "enchantment" guarding the buried treasure would be lifted. Whether or not these reports have any validity, Oliver Harper's widow continued to maintain a family interest in subsequent money digging operations conducted under the supervision of her husband's partner, Josiah Stowell.
--------------------------------------------------------------
R. C. Doud said that in 1822 he was employed with thirteen others by Oliver Harper to dig for gold on Joseph McKune's land under Joe Smith's direction and that Joe had begun operations the previous year. The digging was kept up constantly, with seven digging and seven resting (Emily C. Blackman, History of Susquehanna County, 1873, pp. 580-81).
A resident of the area reported that Harper spent on the treasure quest "$2000 [and] he utterly refused to go any further" (Ibid., p. 580)
--------------------------------------------------------------
"On a wilderness-hill--now a part of Jacob J. Skinner's farm— “peek-stone” discovered a ton of silver bars which had been buried by weary Spaniards as they trudged up the Susquehanna. An expedition for their recovery was undertaken as soon as Smith could muster enough followers to do the work. . . . The third hole had been sunk fifteen out of the necessary twenty feet when the treasure once more jumped to the other side of the big hole. Then the prophet had a vision: the blood of a black sheep must be shed and sprinkled around the diggings. Black sheep were scarce, and while they waited for one, the faithful obtained their needed rest. At length, no black sheep appearing, Joe said that a black dog might answer. A dog, therefore, was killed, and the blood was sprinkled on the ground.
After that the silver never went far away. Still, it waltzed about the big hole in such a lively manner that frequent tunneling to affect its capture availed nothing. At the last, the prophet decided that it was of no use to dig unless one of their number was made a sacrifice. None of the faithful responded to his call, and thus the magnificent scheme was abandoned. Oliver Harper, one of the diggers who furnished the money, was soon afterward murdered. The prophet thought this might answer for a sacrifice: he again rallied the diggers, but the charm remained stubborn and would not reveal the silver" (Lippincott's Magazine, 1880, pp. 199-200).
--------------------------------------------------------------
By the way, the "peeper" who swindled all of Oliver Harpur's money (and many others’)??? Joseph Smith, the self-proclaimed prophet and founder of the Latter Day Saints and the Mormon Church.
More about peep stones and the practice of peeping.
--------------------------------------------------------------
In 1823, shortly after the preceding events, at a location across the Susquehanna River from camp, an angel named Moroni appeared to Joseph Smith and told him of the existence of an ancient record engraved on plates, buried in a hill near his home. Moroni, referred to as the last ancient record keeper to inscribe his teachings on the plates, appeared to Joseph on a number of occasions between 1823 and 1829, guiding and mentoring Joseph as he obtained the plates and translated them using his seer stone.
The story is true but was Jason Treadwell innocent, as he claimed?
Seven years after Jason Treadwell was hung for the murder of Oliver Harper, his brother confessed to the murder. He stated he and Jason conspired for the murder. At the last second, Jason lost his nerve. I grabbed Jason's gun and shot Harper dead. -Susquehanna Historical Society
But what about the confessed killer?
Scant information is available about a report that appeared in the 23 Nov 1888 Susquehanna, Pennsylvania Weekly Journal about a man in New Orleans named Chapman who reportedly confessed on his deathbed to the murder of Oliver Harpur in Susquehanna County.
Another Mormon connection...
Lewis Corners - Crossroad just north of Page Lake. Named for Joseph Lewis, maternal cousin to Emma Hale Smith. Lewis and his wife lived at Lewis Corners in the late 1830s. By 1840, his house was burned to the ground. Lewis was the son of Nathaniel Lewis, an ordained Deacon in the Methodist Episcopal Church in Harmony, PA and a vocal skeptic of Joseph Smith’s early claims regarding the golden plates, stone-gazing, and treasure digging.
Does it rain every July 29th?
July 29, 2022
The Hangman's Rope